He Blamed Gov. Hochul for a Rikers Island Release. Rikers Is a City Jail, Its Detainer Rules Are City Law, and the State Law She Signed Leaves Local Jails Out.

Immigration Source: Facebook Post (official page) FALSE ATTRIBUTION

Why this matters

Who decides whether a jail holds someone for immigration agents matters in NY-23 too. The state court ruling and Attorney General guidance described below apply to sheriffs’ jails across New York, including the county jails in this district. Constituents who read that the governor is blocking cooperation will draw conclusions about state law. This entry checks whether the decision in this case was hers.


Statement

Source: Official Facebook page (Congressman Nick Langworthy), November 17, 2026, linking a New York Post story headlined “Illegal migrant accused of attempted murder at large after Rikers release despite ICE detainer: DHS”:

“This is the infuriating consequence of NYS’s sanctuary policies: an attempted murderer with multiple violent felonies in the country illegally is freely roaming the streets because Hochul won’t allow law enforcement to cooperate with ICE detainers. She would rather protect THIS guy than your safety.”


The record

What DHS says happened

The Department of Homeland Security’s November 17, 2026 release says that on April 29, 2026, “ICE lodged a detainer” for a man “after he had been arrested in Brooklyn for the charges of attempted murder, first-degree assault” and weapons offenses. It says “His criminal history includes a prior arrest for third-degree assault,” that he “illegally overstayed his authorized period after it expired in January 2015,” and that New York officials “RELEASED” him “from Rikers Island back onto the streets on November 7. He currently remains at large.”

DHS describes arrests and charges. Its release does not say he has been convicted of anything. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin’s own statement refers to “these violent charges.” Neither DHS nor the Post says why he was released on November 7, whether by bail, a court order or another outcome in the criminal case.

Who declined the detainer

The Post’s story, credited to Fox News, says the detainer was one “which the New York City Department of Correction declined to honor, allowing him to be released from Rikers Island.” Rikers is run by the city’s Department of Correction, a city agency.

The law the city follows

New York City Administrative Code §9-131, set by Local Law 58 of 2014, governs the Department of Correction. As a federal judge summarized it on October 15, 2026, the department “may honor a section 287.7 detainer request only if (a) federal immigration authorities provide a ‘judicial warrant’ and (b) the individual ‘has been convicted of a violent or serious crime’ or ‘is identified as a possible match in the terrorist screening database.’”

Both conditions must be met. A pending charge, even a serious one, does not meet the conviction requirement. DHS’s release does not say whether ICE presented a judicial warrant.

What state law adds

  • A 2018 state court ruling. In People ex rel. Wells v. DeMarco, the Appellate Division, Second Department, held that “New York state and local law enforcement officers are not authorized by New York law to effectuate arrests for civil law immigration violations.” The Attorney General’s February 2026 guidance says agencies “have authority to honor such detainers if the federal authorities present a judicial warrant.” This ruling came in 2018, before Gov. Hochul took office in August 2021.
  • A federal court in October 2026. Dismissing the Justice Department’s suit against the city’s detainer laws, Judge Ramón Reyes wrote that “even if this Court eliminated sections 9-131(b), 9-205(b), 14-154(b) of New York City’s Administrative Code, New York City officers would still be unable to execute a section 287.7 detainer request to maintain custody of a non-citizen without a judicial warrant.”
  • The 2026 state law Gov. Hochul signed. The budget law enacted this year includes the “Local Cops, Local Crimes Act,” which bars local governments, police and jails from 287(g) agreements with ICE and from contracts to “house or detain individuals for federal civil immigration violations.” Its separate rules on municipal employees and immigration detainers do not reach jails: the law’s definition of “municipal government” says it “shall not include a local correctional facility,” and its definition of “municipal government employee” excludes police officers and peace officers. The law also states it does not bar compliance with federal judicial warrants and court orders.

In plain language: The decision not to hold him was made by New York City’s jail system, under a city law from 2014. That law requires both a judge’s warrant and a conviction, and DHS describes only charges. A federal judge wrote last month that the city could not have held him on a detainer without a judge’s warrant even if the city law did not exist. The state law Gov. Hochul signed this year limits local cooperation with ICE in other ways, but it leaves local jails out of its detainer rules.

What Gov. Hochul has said

At the August 25, 2026 announcement of the new law, Gov. Hochul said: “Once they’re convicted and do their time, we work with ICE to ensure they’re deported… New York State will never become a sanctuary for criminals.” She added that “local police will assist ICE only if a real crime has been committed.” Her spokesperson told Fox News Digital for the Post’s story: “By law, New York State always notifies federal immigration enforcement of any non-citizen serving a State prison sentence.” That statement concerns state prisons, not city jails like Rikers.


The fair reading

Parts of the post match what DHS says. ICE lodged a detainer, it was not honored, the man was released from Rikers on November 7, and DHS says he is at large and overstayed his authorized stay. Gov. Hochul did sign a 2026 law that restricts local cooperation with ICE, and New York’s courts have limited civil immigration arrests by local officers since 2018. “NYS’s sanctuary policies” describes something real.

Three parts do not hold up. “An attempted murderer with multiple violent felonies” describes charges as convictions; DHS lists arrests and charges. “Because Hochul won’t allow law enforcement to cooperate with ICE detainers” assigns the decision to the governor, when the city’s Department of Correction made it under city law, a 2018 court ruling and the federal judicial-warrant requirement a federal judge described last month, while the state law she signed excludes local jails from its detainer rules. And “She would rather protect THIS guy than your safety” is a claim about her motive, which her own public statements contradict and no evidence supports.

Verdict: FALSE ATTRIBUTION. The release followed a New York City jail policy set by city law in 2014, under rules a state court set in 2018, before she took office. The post attributes it to Gov. Hochul and describes a man charged with crimes as convicted of them.


Questions This Raises

  1. Did ICE present a judicial warrant with this detainer? DHS’s release does not say.
  2. His post calls the man “an attempted murderer with multiple violent felonies.” What conviction is that based on?
  3. Will he say whether he supports changing the city law, the 2018 court ruling’s effect, or the 2026 state law, and which would have changed the outcome here?

Sources


Note: This entry documents statutes, court decisions, a federal agency’s statement and Rep. Langworthy’s own words. It makes no claim about motive. The person DHS identified has been charged, not convicted, and is presumed innocent.

Last updated: November 19, 2026