He Says the Grid Operator's Shortfall Warning Is 'Exactly' What He Predicted About the Gas Ban. The Report Never Mentions That Law, Which Is Already on Hold.
Why this matters
New York’s grid operator says the state could be short of electricity in the 2030s. That affects every household in NY-23, and Rep. Langworthy has a stake in the fix: he wants the shuttered Dunkirk coal plant in Chautauqua County repowered with natural gas, and his Energy Choice Act would bar states from banning gas hookups. How he describes the warning matters, because the report’s causes point to different solutions.
Statement
Source: Official Facebook page (Congressman Nick Langworthy), November 19, 2026, linking the NYISO press release:
“This is a five-alarm warning for Governor Hochul and every Democrat legislator in Albany that their dangerous, reckless push to full electrification will have catastrophic consequences if allowed to go forward. These findings are exactly what I’ve been warning about and cannot be ignored–I’m calling on them to permanently suspend and repeal their natural gas ban before New Yorkers’ safety is compromised.”
Source: Press release, November 19, 2026:
“The findings in this report detail the exact outcome I have been talking about since day one, and why I’ve fought to block this disastrous law from taking effect.”
The release calls on Gov. Hochul “to immediately suspend implementation of New York’s All-Electric Buildings Act and work with the State Legislature to permanently repeal the law,” and renews his call “to repurpose the shuttered Dunkirk coal plant for natural gas.”
Source: Official Facebook page, a follow-up post linking the same press release:
“The dangerous impact of Hochul & Albany Dems extreme mass electrification ban is no longer theoretical—the facts are at our front door. We are going to run out of power if we don’t act to add more supply in the system and that means an all-of-the-above approach, including natural gas. Repeal the gas ban now!”
The record
What the grid operator found
The New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) runs the state’s power grid. Its 2026 Reliability Needs Assessment, dated November 17 and announced November 18, found “a first-ever statewide resource deficiency.” The shortfall begins at about 225 megawatts in 2033 and grows to more than 1,850 megawatts by 2036. It also found local shortfalls in New York City and the Lower Hudson Valley starting in 2032.
What NYISO says is causing it
In its own words, the findings “reflect the convergence of several trends: growing electricity demand, greater uncertainty and limitations regarding assistance from neighboring regions, and significant reductions in available in-state energy supply.” On each:
| Cause NYISO names | What the report says |
|---|---|
| New large customers | “The growing demand is especially driven by approximately 2,700 MW of planned large loads, including 1,000 MW of industrial facilities and 1,700 MW of computational data centers” |
| Aging power plants | “New York has the oldest generation fleet in the entire country.” About 2,600 MW is projected to be unavailable by 2036 |
| Less help from neighbors | “Neighboring regions are also experiencing similar demand growth, resulting in less opportunity for assistance” |
| Gas plants unavailable in winter | The fact sheet projects 5,400 MW of gas-fired generation “to be unavailable under winter peak conditions” |
| A state law retiring gas plants | The New York Power Authority’s small gas plants, 517 MW, are assumed retired after 2030; “their assumed retirement driven by state law materially contributes to each of the three identified Reliability Needs” |
Where electrification fits
Electrification is in the report. NYISO lists “building electrification” and “electric vehicles” among the factors increasing demand, and says recent load growth projections “are tightly tied to specific state policies contributing to the electrification of building space conditioning and transportation.” It says “electrification and large loads have a significant impact on the projected increase in the forecasts.” By 2036, winter accounts for about 40% of the statewide shortfall risk, “due to increasing demand from heating electrification, as well as fuel-related generation constraints.” In an informational scenario with faster electrification and earlier retirements, the 2036 shortfall grows to 3,300 megawatts.
What the report does not say
The report never mentions the All-Electric Buildings Act, a “gas ban,” or gas hookups. A text search of the report and the fact sheet finds none of those terms. NYISO’s recommended response is “a combination of new generation, repowered resources, energy storage, dependable demand reductions, flexible large loads, and additional transmission.”
“At our front door”
The report looks ten years ahead. Its first statewide shortfall is projected for 2033, about seven years from now, and the local needs in New York City and the Lower Hudson Valley start in 2032. NYISO’s fact sheet describes a reliability need as “an early warning that the grid is projected to fall short of the standards required to reliably supply or deliver electricity,” and says federal rules require NYISO to “identify and evaluate solutions to address those needs before they affect reliable service.” Its press release says that if the needs remain after updates to plans and forecasts, “the NYISO will solicit and evaluate market-based and regulated solutions through development of the 2027-2036 Comprehensive Reliability Plan.”
The follow-up post’s call for “more supply” and “an all-of-the-above approach, including natural gas” fits the report, which lists new generation and repowered plants among its solutions. The report does not predict that the state will run out of power. It projects that the grid would fall short of reliability standards starting in 2033 unless plans, forecasts or resources change.
In plain language: NYISO’s report gives his argument some support. State electrification policy is one of the things pushing demand up, and a state law retiring gas plants makes the shortfall worse. But the report’s leading cause is new data centers and factories, followed by old plants and less help from neighboring states. It does not single out the law he wants repealed.
The law he wants suspended is already suspended
The All-Electric Buildings Act, passed in the 2023 state budget, bans gas hookups in new buildings under seven stories and would extend to all new buildings in 2029. It does not apply to existing buildings.
- In November 2025, before the law’s January 1, 2026 start date, the state agreed in federal court to delay it while gas and construction groups appealed (Spectrum News).
- On June 30, 2026, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the law, ruling that federal appliance law does not preempt it. Rehearing was denied August 26.
- Under the state’s agreement, the delay lasts until 120 days after the appeals court rules or, if the case goes to the Supreme Court, 120 days after the Supreme Court acts. The challengers asked the Supreme Court to take the case on November 13, 2026 (Public Health Law Center case tracker).
So the law is on hold today, and stays on hold while the Supreme Court petition is pending. His call to “immediately suspend implementation” asks for something already in place. His call to repeal it permanently is a separate question for the Legislature.
“Since day one”
His record on this issue is long. On October 26, 2023, he introduced the Energy Choice Act, warning that the state’s effort to ban gas in buildings would “eliminate a reliable and necessary source of energy that keeps homes heated and people safe.” He reintroduced it as H.R. 3699 on June 4, 2025. It has 157 cosponsors, 154 Republicans and 3 Democrats. The Energy and Commerce Committee voted 24-21 on December 3, 2025 to report it, and filed its report on February 4, 2026. It has not reached the House floor.
Context
NYISO’s warnings are disputed. After NYISO’s June 2025 Power Trends report, four environmental groups, Earthjustice, the Environmental Defense Fund, WE ACT for Environmental Justice and Evergreen Action, wrote to Gov. Hochul on July 7, 2025 that the report’s suggestion that more gas generation was needed “is not supported by NYISO’s own analysis.” That letter concerned the earlier report, not this one. Republican state senators cited the same 2025 report to urge more gas pipelines and plant upgrades (News10).
The fair reading
He has warned for three years that ending new gas hookups would strain reliability, and the new report confirms the state faces a supply problem. NYISO does count electrification as a real source of new demand, especially in winter, and it does say a state law retiring gas plants worsens every shortfall it found. His call for more supply, including gas, matches the new and repowered generation NYISO says it will need. Those parts of his argument have support in the report.
What the posts leave out is how NYISO itself ranks the causes, with data centers and factories first, and that the report never names the law he wants repealed. They also leave out that the law is on hold, and stays on hold while the Supreme Court petition is pending. And “the facts are at our front door” describes a shortfall NYISO projects for 2033, in a report it calls an early warning meant to start a search for solutions. NYISO’s fact sheet adds a point that cuts against relying on gas alone: it expects 5,400 megawatts of gas-fired plants to be unavailable at winter peaks.
Verdict: MISSING CONTEXT. The shortfall warning is real, and electrification is one of its causes. Presenting it as confirmation of the case against the All-Electric Buildings Act omits that NYISO’s leading cause is new large customers, that the report never mentions that law, and that the law is already suspended.
Questions This Raises
- NYISO says 1,700 megawatts of the new demand comes from data centers. What is his position on how data centers in New York should be supplied?
- Would repowering the Dunkirk plant address the shortfalls NYISO found, which are largest in New York City and the Lower Hudson Valley?
- NYISO counts the state-law retirement of the NYPA gas plants as a cause. Has he asked the state to revisit that law?
Sources
- Rep. Langworthy, official Facebook page, November 19, 2026 (screenshot on file; text quoted above)
- Rep. Langworthy, official Facebook page, follow-up post linking the November 19 press release (screenshot on file; text quoted above)
- Rep. Langworthy, press release, November 19, 2026: https://langworthy.house.gov/media/press-releases/congressman-langworthy-calls-governor-hochul-permanently-suspend-and-repeal (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119212542/https://langworthy.house.gov/media/press-releases/congressman-langworthy-calls-governor-hochul-permanently-suspend-and-repeal)
- NYISO, press release, “NYISO Report Identifies First-Ever Statewide Resource Deficiency”: https://www.nyiso.com/-/press-release-nyiso-report-identifies-first-ever-statewide-resource-deficiency (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119212716/https://www.nyiso.com/-/press-release-nyiso-report-identifies-first-ever-statewide-resource-deficiency)
- NYISO, 2026 Reliability Needs Assessment: https://www.nyiso.com/documents/20142/2248793/2026RNA-Report-Final.pdf (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119165438/https://www.nyiso.com/documents/20142/2248793/2026RNA-Report-Final.pdf) ; fact sheet: https://www.nyiso.com/documents/d/guest/2026-rna-fact-sheet-final (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119213002/https://www.nyiso.com/documents/d/guest/2026-rna-fact-sheet-final)
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, Association of Contracting Plumbers v. City of New York; Mulhern Gas Co. v. Mosley, Nos. 25-977, 25-2041 (June 30, 2026): https://dos.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2026/07/decision-mulhern-gas-v.-mosley-2d-cir.pdf (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119213124/https://dos.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2026/07/decision-mulhern-gas-v.-mosley-2d-cir.pdf)
- Public Health Law Center, litigation tracker, Mulhern Gas Co. v. Mosley: https://www.publichealthlawcenter.org/litigation-tracker/mulhern-gas-co-v-mosley-2023 (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119213248/https://www.publichealthlawcenter.org/litigation-tracker/mulhern-gas-co-v-mosley-2023)
- Spectrum News, “New York agrees to delay all-electric buildings mandate,” November 12, 2025: https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/politics/2025/11/12/new-york-agrees-to-delay-all-electric-buildings-mandate (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119213421/https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/politics/2025/11/12/new-york-agrees-to-delay-all-electric-buildings-mandate)
- govinfo BILLSTATUS, H.R. 3699 (Energy Choice Act): https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr3699.xml (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119213552/https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr3699.xml)
- Rep. Langworthy, press release, October 26, 2023: https://langworthy.house.gov/media/press-releases/congressman-nick-langworthy-introduces-energy-choice-act-end-blue-state-wars (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20261119213716/https://langworthy.house.gov/media/press-releases/congressman-nick-langworthy-introduces-energy-choice-act-end-blue-state-wars)
- News10, “NYISO report sparks debate over energy policies in New York,” July 9, 2025, including the July 7, 2025 environmental groups’ letter: https://www.news10.com/news/ny-capitol-news/new-york-energy-policy-debate/ (archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20251115014505/https://www.news10.com/news/ny-capitol-news/new-york-energy-policy-debate/)
Related
Note: This entry documents the grid operator’s report, court records and Rep. Langworthy’s own statements. It makes no claim about motive.
Last updated: November 22, 2026