Who Drew NY-23: A Court in 2022, the Legislature in 2024. His 'Fair Maps' Claim Holds Up. 'A Gerrymander' That Won 'Two Seats' Needs Context.

Elections / Redistricting Source: Interview (Erie News Now Washington Bureau, via WZMQ) and WETM debate MOSTLY TRUE

Why this matters

NY-23 is a safely Republican district. Rep. Langworthy won it by about 20 points this month. A common response from his critics is that the district is gerrymandered. This entry checks that claim against the court record and the maps themselves, and checks what Rep. Langworthy has said about New York’s maps.

The short version: the lines were drawn by a court in 2022 and redrawn by the Legislature in 2024. No court has found either version to be a gerrymander. The only New York map a court did find to be a partisan gerrymander was struck down before it was ever used, and it would have made NY-23 more Republican, not less.


The statements

Source: Erie News Now Washington Bureau, published by WZMQ, June 15, 2026, in a story on mid-decade redistricting.

“I think redistricting needs to be once every decade. This process is played out in a super political way around the country.”

“Democrats in Albany and here in Washington from New York lose sight of the fact that we’ve already had a gerrymander that’s led to them taking two seats in the last election.”

“They did that partisan redistricting, when the courts put fair maps on the table, that we ran on, that were very representative of the population in New York.”

Source: WETM debate, October 6, 2026. Asked his opinion of states that redrew their congressional districts this year:

“I believe that redistricting should be done once a decade.”


Three maps in five years

MapDrawn byStatusNY-23’s lean
February 2022The LegislatureStruck down April 27, 2022, never usedFiveThirtyEight: R+26
May 2022A court-appointed special masterUsed in the 2022 electionFiveThirtyEight: R+23. 2020 presidential vote: Trump 57.6%, Biden 40.4%
February 2024The Legislature (Chapter 92 of 2024)Used in 2024 and 20262020 presidential vote: Trump 58.1%, Biden 39.9%. 2024: Trump 60.1%, Harris 39.1%

FiveThirtyEight’s partisan lean and the presidential results by district, calculated by The Downballot, are different measures. Compare within a column, not across.

The 2022 map that was struck down. The Court of Appeals, New York’s top court, held that the Legislature had bypassed the constitutional process, creating maps “in a nontransparent manner controlled exclusively by the dominant political party.” A majority of the court also held that the congressional map was “substantively unconstitutional as drawn with impermissible partisan purpose,” after the Appellate Division found it was “drawn to discourage competition and favor democrats.” Four of the seven judges joined that holding. That version of NY-23 ran from Chautauqua County east through Steuben and Tioga into parts of Broome and Chenango counties, and FiveThirtyEight listed two Republican incumbents in it.

The 2022 court map. The case had been filed in Steuben County. The trial judge there, Justice Patrick McAllister, appointed Dr. Jonathan Cervas as special master and adopted his maps on May 20, 2022. The judge wrote that “the maps remain almost perfectly neutral, meaning the maps do not favor or disfavor any political party,” and that “Location of a candidate received zero consideration from the court.” Cervas wrote that the maps “were drawn blind to the homes of incumbents,” and that “Most of these indicators show a slight Republican bias” for the map statewide. The Princeton Gerrymandering Project grades the court map A overall: A for partisan fairness, A for geography, C for competitiveness. Its report card for the struck legislative map currently gives it a D overall, with a Democratic partisan advantage.

The 2024 map. In December 2023, the Court of Appeals ruled 4 to 3 that under the 2014 constitutional amendments, “New York courts no longer have the blanket authority to create decade-long redistricting plans,” and ordered the redistricting commission to try again. The commission approved a plan 9 to 1 on February 15, 2024, which WAMC reported left the court’s map “largely intact.” The Legislature rejected it and passed its own map on February 28, 2024, 115 to 33 in the Assembly and 45 to 17 in the Senate, with what WAMC reported as “a handful of Republican minority party lawmakers also voting yes.” The governor signed it that day.

In plain language: the one map a court found to be rigged was drawn by Democrats, would have made NY-23 more Republican in order to help Democrats elsewhere, and was thrown out. The neutral map a court drew, without looking at where incumbents lived, voted for Trump by 17 points in 2020. The 2024 Legislature’s version is about one point more Republican than that. Under every version drawn so far, NY-23 is a Republican district.


What the 2024 map changed in NY-23

Census Bureau relationship files for the 118th and 119th Congresses show which towns moved. Populations are the Census Bureau’s 2020 base counts.

Moved out of NY-23PopulationNow in
Lackawanna (Erie)19,961NY-26
Most of West Seneca (Erie)Part of 45,528NY-26
Avoca, Cohocton, Dansville, Prattsburgh, Pulteney, Wayland, Wheeler (Steuben)14,205NY-24
Hector, Reading, Tyrone (Schuyler)8,253NY-24
Moved into NY-23Population
All nine towns of Tioga County48,458
Pendleton (Niagara)7,034
Part of the town of Lockport and a small part of Wheatfield (Niagara)Not available at the town level

NY-23 now contains all of Allegany, Cattaraugus, Chautauqua, Chemung and Tioga counties, and parts of Erie, Niagara, Schuyler and Steuben.

In plain language: the 2024 map swapped some suburbs south of Buffalo and seven northeastern Steuben towns for Tioga County and a slice of Niagara County. Where a town was split, the Census files give land area, not people, so this entry does not estimate the population of the pieces.

His home town. Rep. Langworthy’s official House biography says he and his wife “currently reside in Pendleton, NY,” and Niagara County property records show he has owned a home there since May 2021. Under the 2022 court map, which was drawn “blind to the homes of incumbents,” Pendleton was in NY-26. For his first term he represented a district he did not live in, which the Constitution allows; House members must live only in their state. The Legislature’s 2024 map moved all of Pendleton into NY-23. Pendleton borders Clarence, which is in NY-23 under both maps, so the change keeps the district in one piece. New York’s constitution says districts shall not be drawn “for the purpose of favoring or disfavoring incumbents.” This site has found no record of why Pendleton was moved or whether anyone asked for the change.


“A gerrymander that’s led to them taking two seats”

No court has found the 2024 map to be a partisan gerrymander. The one court challenge to it this site found, over NY-11 on Staten Island, was a voting rights claim. The U.S. Supreme Court stayed a lower-court order to redraw that district on March 2, 2026, and the parties dismissed the case with prejudice on March 19.

What the 2024 map did do is shift a few districts. Measured by the 2020 presidential vote on each set of lines:

District2020 margin, court lines2020 margin, 2024 linesChange2024 House result
NY-22Biden +7.5Biden +11.43.9 points toward DemocratsDemocrat gained the seat, won by 9.1
NY-3Biden +8.2Biden +11.33.1 toward DemocratsDemocrat held the seat, won by 3.6
NY-4Biden +14.5Biden +14.5NoneDemocrat gained the seat, won by 2.3
NY-19Biden +4.6Biden +4.50.1 toward RepublicansDemocrat gained the seat, won by 2.2
NY-1Biden +0.2Trump +1.82.0 toward RepublicansRepublican held
NY-23Trump +17.2Trump +18.21.0 toward RepublicansRepublican held
NY-24Trump +17.2Trump +20.33.1 toward RepublicansRepublican held

House margins are two-party shares of all votes on each candidate’s party lines, from the House Clerk’s official 2024 statistics.

In plain language: he is right that the 2024 map moved two districts, NY-3 and NY-22, toward Democrats, and Democrats won both. But Democrats had already won NY-3 on the court’s lines: Rep. Tom Suozzi took the oath for the seat on February 28, 2024, after a special election, the same day the new map was signed. In NY-22, the Democrat’s margin was more than twice the shift. Two of the three seats Democrats gained in 2024, NY-4 and NY-19, were essentially unchanged by the new map. The same map also moved NY-1, NY-23 and NY-24 toward Republicans. Whether any seat would have gone the other way on the old lines cannot be known from these numbers.


“Once a decade”

He has said this twice this year, and it fits what he said as state party chairman in 2022. Then, he called the Legislature’s first map “textbook filthy, partisan gerrymandering” (WSKG, February 2, 2022) and greeted the court’s maps with: “Today is a good day for democracy” (New York Republican State Committee, May 21, 2022). In August 2025, responding to Gov. Hochul’s talk of redrawing New York’s map after Texas redrew its own, he told WIVB: “She can’t do that before the midterm elections. That’s all political posturing.”

New York is now partway down that road. On June 3, 2026, the Legislature gave first passage to a constitutional amendment (S.10637-A/A.11553-A). It would let the Legislature change congressional districts before the 2030 census, and those changes “shall not be subject to any of the provisions” of the sections that now bar districts drawn “for the purpose of favoring or disfavoring incumbents or other particular candidates or political parties.” The amendment must pass the Legislature again in 2027 and then win a statewide vote. On November 12, Gov. Hochul said, “We’re halfway there,” without committing to the second step.

Two House bills would write his position into federal law by barring states from redistricting more than once after each census. H.R. 4889, introduced by Rep. Kevin Kiley of California in August 2025, does only that. H.R. 7219, Rep. Mike Lawler’s FAIR MAP Act, does it along with other provisions. Rep. Langworthy is not a cosponsor of either, according to their govinfo bill status records, and the Clerk lists one signature on the discharge petition for H.R. 4889 (No. 21): Rep. Kiley’s.


Claims checked

ClaimFinding
“When the courts put fair maps on the table, that we ran on”TRUE. The 2022 map was drawn by a court-appointed special master without regard to incumbents’ homes. The court called it “almost perfectly neutral,” and the Princeton Gerrymandering Project grades it A. He ran on it in 2022.
“We’ve already had a gerrymander that’s led to them taking two seats in the last election”MISSING CONTEXT. The 2024 map moved NY-3 and NY-22 toward Democrats, and Democrats won both. But NY-3 had already flipped on the court’s lines, the NY-22 winner’s margin was more than double the shift, and no court has found the 2024 map to be a gerrymander.
“Redistricting should be done once a decade”Not rated. This is a stated position. It is consistent with his statements about New York since 2022.

Overall: MOSTLY TRUE. His description of the 2022 court map holds up. His “two seats” claim is partly right and leaves out context.


So is NY-23 gerrymandered?

On the record, no. Its current lines are the Legislature’s 2024 map, not the court’s 2022 map, but no court has found the 2024 map to be a partisan gerrymander. NY-23 was Republican by double digits under the court’s neutral version, and it is about a point more Republican under the current one.


The fair reading

  • A district can be lopsided without being gerrymandered. Who lives where matters, and these counties have voted Republican under every map drawn for them this decade.
  • He is consistent on New York. His “once a decade” position matches what he said in 2022, and New York’s Democratic Legislature is the one now moving to allow a mid-decade redraw.
  • His “two seats” line has a factual core. The 2024 map did help Democrats in two districts, and Democrats won both.

Questions this raises

  1. Does his “once a decade” position extend to the mid-decade redraws in Texas and other Republican-led states in 2025 and 2026? The statements this site located address New York.
  2. Will he cosponsor H.R. 4889, or a successor bill in the 120th Congress, which would make his stated position federal law?
  3. Which two seats did he mean? He has not named them.
  4. Did he, his office or his party ask the Legislature to put Pendleton, his home town, in NY-23 in 2024?

What is still unaddressed

ItemStatus
Population of the split towns (West Seneca, Lockport, Wheatfield) on each side of the lineNot computed; Census town files give land area only
A Princeton grade for the 2024 mapNone located
How the state Republican Party was involved in the 2022 lawsuitHe said “We took on this fight”; this site has not located records of the party funding or organizing the suit

Sources



Note: This entry documents court decisions, statutes, Census Bureau files and official election results alongside Rep. Langworthy’s own statements. It makes no claim about motive.

Last updated: November 13, 2026 (same-day addition: his home town and the 2024 map)